The shortfall of monkeypox vaccine doses in the United States, expected to last for months, is raising urgent questions about how well and for how long a single shot can protect against the virus.
The vaccine, called Jynneos, is approved as a two-dose regimen, but most people at risk of infection have been receiving one dose – if they can find it. Now the shortage has led federal officials to consider a rarely used approach: a so-called dose-sparing strategy, which gives shots that each contain just one-fifth of a single dose.
For most recipients, one shot should be enough to ward off serious illness, and there is some evidence that even smaller doses can be effective. But preliminary research suggests that people with HIV or other conditions that weaken the immune system may be less protected than people who do not have such illnesses, according to some experts.
“One dose is better than none,” said Dr. Alexandra Yonts, an infectious diseases physician at Children’s National Hospital in Washington, DC But people with “HIV and other immunocompromised individuals need to be aware that they may not have an adequate level of protection from infection, even with vaccination,” she added.
Even two weeks after the shot, when the antibody response is underway, immunocompromised people may still need to “use all other precautions to prevent being exposed, according to public health guidance,” she said.
The findings also suggest that some men should be prioritized for full vaccination. Given the supply constraints, that may be difficult.
Federal officials have ordered nearly seven million doses of Jynneos, but the shots will not arrive for months. So far, the Biden administration has shipped about 600,000 doses to states. It said last week that 800,000 additional doses were being allocated to states, but the distribution could take weeks.
Faced with shortages, some cities, including Washington and New York, are restricting second doses to stretch their supplies. Officials at the Food and Drug Administration and the CDC have disagreed with that strategy, noting that Jynneos is approved as a vaccine to be given in two doses spaced 28 days apart.
But as federal health officials declared a public health emergency on Thursday, Dr. Robert Califf, the commissioner of the FDA, said the agency was now considering authorizing shots that contain just one-fifth of the regular dose, delivered between layers of the skin instead of under it.
The Fight Against HIV
An estimated 40 million people are living with HIV worldwide. About 10 million of them do not have access to treatment.
The FDA would need to grant Jynneos an emergency use authorization in order for it to be administered this way.
The dose-sparing approach has been used when supplies of other vaccines are scarce. But giving intradermal shots requires more skill than is needed for more traditional immunizations.
One shot is probably enough to forestall severe symptoms in most people, and the dose-sparing strategy may work just as well. But it’s unclear whether a scaled-back regimen is enough to prevent infection, and if so, how long that immunity may last, federal health officials said.
“We’re in a data-free zone,” said Dr. Emily Erbelding, an infectious diseases expert at the National Institutes of Health, who oversaw testing of Covid vaccines in special populations.
One oft-cited statistic says that the vaccine is 85 percent effective against monkeypox. That data derives not from trials of Jynneos, but from a small 1988 study that looked at the incidence of monkeypox among people who had been inoculated for smallpox earlier in their lives.
No large clinical trial of Jynneos as a monkeypox vaccine was conducted in humans before its approval. Instead, the FDA relied on measures of antibody responses in small groups of people after immunization with Jynneos compared with those produced by ACAM2000, an earlier vaccine for smallpox.
In studies led by its manufacturer, Bavarian Nordic, two doses of Jynneos yielded antibody levels in humans that were about the same as those after one shot of ACAM2000.
Antibody levels after the first shot of Jynneos initially rose for two weeks and then remained flat until the second dose four weeks later, when they soared to very high levels — higher than those recorded with ACAM2000.
Scientists read that to mean that if the first dose is not followed by a second, the protection may not be long-lasting.
“Ideally, a second dose would be administered if protection for more than that four-week period is desired,” said Dr. Yonts, who reviewed the data for the FDA as a staff scientist.
She added that delaying the second dose to eight weeks might be reasonable. “But if it’s going to be like six months, then I think that prioritization would lean more towards those who are more severely immunocompromised,” she said.
Injecting one-fifth of a regular dose of Jynneos between skin layers, as the FDA suggested on Thursday, may be effective, according to limited research. The skin has many more immune cells that respond to vaccines.
But the research is very limited. Scientists at the NIH planned to test the dose-saving strategy in a clinical trial set to begin in a few weeks. It is unclear whether those plans will be shelved or sped up.
Information about how Jynneos performs in people with HIV, particularly in those with severe immune problems, was already scant. In one study conducted by Bavarian Nordic, antibody response to vaccination tended to be diminished: At 28 days after the first shot, 67 percent of those with HIV produced antibodies, compared with 84 percent of uninfected people.
While Dr. Yonts said the data from that trial was not conclusive, reduced antibody response is often seen among immunocompromised people given other vaccines. While evaluating Covid vaccines, for example, researchers found that patients with HIV were more likely to have breakthrough infections.
“Individuals with severe or moderate immune suppression are recommended for additional doses of common vaccines,” said Keri Althoff, an epidemiologist at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, who led the Covid vaccine study. “As immune suppression increases, the response to the vaccines does decrease.”
The CDC and the New York City Department of Health say Jynneos is safe for people with HIV, but the agencies have not addressed its effectiveness in that population.
By contrast, health officials in Britain say that for people who “are HIV positive or have any other condition or treatment leading to a weakened immune system, the vaccine may not protect you as well.”
The vaccine’s package insert also notes that immunocompromised people “may have a diminished immune response.”
“Two shots may be very important in this population, which is something that is not actually happening in the public health response,” said Dr. Chloe Orkin, an infectious disease physician at Queen Mary University of London, referring to immunocompromised people.
But until more doses are available, state and local health departments may not have much of a choice other than to stick with scaled-back regimens.
“In an environment of scarcity, we have to do everything we can to get the benefits of the vaccine to the city as quickly as possible,” said Patrick Gallahue, a spokesman for New York City’s health department, in a statement.